Skip to main content
Available 24/7 for urgent criminal matters.New York City & Long Island   646 663 4430
646 663 4430 Call
  1. Home
  2. Practice Areas
  3. New York Menacing in the Second Degree Lawyer

LEBEDIN KOFMAN LLP

New York Menacing in the Second Degree Lawyer

On this page
  1. What does Penal Law 120.14 prohibit?
  2. What must the prosecution prove?
  3. How the three menacing degrees differ
  4. Examples of issues that change the analysis
  5. Defense and evidence issues to investigate
  6. Possible penalties and consequences
  7. What happens after an arrest or appearance ticket?
  8. Menacing, assault and other related allegations
  9. Discuss the allegation with Lebedin Kofman LLP
  10. Frequently asked questions

A weapon display, repeated threatening encounters or an allegation involving a stay-away order can lead to a second-degree menacing charge. The accusation does not answer which legal theory applies or what the evidence establishes. Keep the charging papers, preserve original recordings and messages, and identify the next court date before discussing the incident with investigators.

Lebedin Kofman LLP handles New York criminal defense matters. Request a free consultation or 646 663 4430 to discuss the charge and immediate restrictions. Do not send highly sensitive evidence through the website inquiry form.

What does Penal Law 120.14 prohibit?

Section 120.14 provides three alternatives. The defense needs the actual subdivision rather than the shorthand word “menacing.”

  1. Weapon display: intentionally placing or attempting to place another person in reasonable fear of physical injury, serious physical injury or death by displaying a deadly weapon, dangerous instrument or what appears to be a pistol, revolver, rifle, shotgun, machine gun or other firearm.
  2. Repeated conduct: repeatedly following someone, engaging in a course of conduct or repeatedly committing acts over time, intentionally placing or attempting to place that person in reasonable fear of physical injury, serious physical injury or death. A weapon is not an element of this alternative.
  3. Stay-away order: committing third-degree menacing in violation of the part of an order directing the accused to stay away from its protected person or persons. The order must have been duly served, or the accused must have actual knowledge because they were present in court when it was issued. The statute covers orders under Family Court Act Article Eight, CPL 530.12, or a competent court in another state, territorial or tribal jurisdiction. The prosecution must establish the underlying physical menace and intent required by third-degree menacing as well as these order-related conditions.

Not every argument meets one of these theories. Nor is physical contact required in every menacing allegation. Review the asserted conduct, timing and mental state together.

The wording “places or attempts to place” matters: an unsuccessful effort to cause the required fear can still fall within the statute. For the apparent-firearm display theory, separately examine the CJI’s requirement that the other person perceived the manifested object as a firearm. Do not substitute a generic “attempt” label for the evidence required by the particular alternative.

What must the prosecution prove?

Under CPL 70.20, a conviction by verdict requires legally sufficient trial evidence establishing every element and the accused person’s commission of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt. A police description, arrest or charging decision is not itself that proof.

Intent concerns the person’s conscious objective. Counsel should distinguish deliberate intimidation from an accidental movement or an encounter described without its surrounding context. The fact that someone was upset does not automatically establish the mental state alleged.

The Criminal Jury Instructions for the weapon-display alternative explain that an apparent firearm need not actually be a firearm. They address a consciously displayed or manifested object that could reasonably be perceived as a firearm and was perceived that way. A dangerous instrument also turns on its capacity in the particular circumstances. “It was not a real gun” therefore does not resolve every display allegation.

A dangerous instrument is an instrument, article or substance, including a vehicle, readily capable of causing death or serious physical injury in the circumstances of its use, attempted use or threatened use. An everyday object is not automatically a dangerous instrument in every setting, nor must it actually cause serious injury to meet this definition. The evidence must establish how it was used or threatened to be used.

How the three menacing degrees differ

New York menacing statutes: charge distinctions, not outcome predictions
ChargeDistinctive issueClassification
Third degree — 120.15By physical menace, intentionally placing or attempting to place another person in fear of death, imminent serious physical injury or imminent physical injury.Class B misdemeanor
Second degree — 120.14One of the weapon-display, repeated-conduct or stay-away-order alternatives explained above.Class A misdemeanor
First degree — 120.13Second-degree menacing plus a previous conviction of second-degree menacing or menacing a police officer or peace officer within the preceding ten years.Class E felony

Third-degree menacing and first-degree menacing have their own elements. A prior conviction of any kind does not automatically establish first-degree menacing. Counsel should obtain the actual disposition and compare it with the statutory requirement.

Under Penal Law 10.00, physical injury means impairment of physical condition or substantial pain. Serious physical injury involves a substantial risk of death, death, serious and protracted disfigurement, protracted impairment of health, or protracted loss or impairment of an organ’s function. These definitions describe the injury feared in the second-degree charge; the statute does not require that such injury actually occur.

Examples of issues that change the analysis

These examples are hypothetical. They illustrate questions for investigation, not firm results or predictions of acquittal.

A disputed object during an argument

A witness describes a gun-shaped object raised toward them. Another recording shows only the back of the person’s hand. The investigation should identify the complete footage, viewing angles, lighting, words spoken and what the witness actually perceived. Discovering a harmless object may matter, but the apparent-firearm theory requires more analysis than simply testing whether it could fire.

Several encounters described as repeated following

Two people share a commuting route. One describes several encounters as deliberate intimidation; the other says the overlap was incidental. Dates, route records, messages and independent witnesses may help assess whether the alleged pattern and intent are supported. Counsel should examine each episode rather than accepting a collection of summaries as one undifferentiated event.

Repeated encounters alone do not establish a conscious objective to place the other person in reasonable fear of physical injury, serious physical injury or death. Counsel should examine the alleged following or course of conduct, what happened during each encounter and the evidence of that objective. This theory does not require a weapon, but it does require more than proving that two people were in the same places.

An encounter involving a stay-away order

A complaint refers to an order without attaching the full terms. The defense should obtain the order, court record and evidence concerning service or the accused person’s presence when it was issued. It must also analyze the conduct alleged as third-degree menacing. A complainant’s invitation is not a substitute for a court modification; continue obeying the current order.

Defense and evidence issues to investigate

A defense should address the charged alternative, not rely on a general promise that menacing is easy to dismiss. Issues can include identity, the completeness and reliability of recordings, the required intent, the alleged display, the claimed pattern over time, and the exact order and notice evidence. Where relevant, counsel should also assess justification under the applicable law and the way police obtained statements or evidence.

A factual defense to an element is different from a statutory affirmative defense. Under Penal Law 25.00, the prosecution must disprove an ordinary statutory defense beyond a reasonable doubt when raised at trial. For a defense expressly declared an affirmative defense, the accused must establish it by a preponderance of the evidence. The prosecution still bears the burden of proving the offense’s elements.

Justification requires care about the conduct being justified. In People v. Montanez (Appellate Term, 2007), the court distinguished displaying a gun toward the ground from using physical force and upheld a justification instruction under 35.05(2) rather than 35.15(1). That fact-specific decision is an illustration, not a promise that a weapon display is justified. Counsel must assess the actual conduct, applicable statutory conditions and current controlling law.

  • Preserve the original video and audio, including events before and after the disputed moment.
  • Keep complete message threads, dates, account information and devices; screenshots may omit useful context.
  • Identify neutral witnesses and where they stood or what they actually observed.
  • Retain the complaint, appearance notice, order of protection and release papers.
  • Tell counsel who may hold building, store or transit recordings before they are overwritten.

Do not edit source files, delete material or ask another person to contact a protected individual. Ask the attorney how to preserve and transfer records securely.

Possible penalties and consequences

Second-degree menacing is a class A misdemeanor. Penal Law 70.15 caps its definite jail sentence at 364 days. The ordinary class A misdemeanor fine ceiling is $1,000 under 80.05, subject to any applicable statutory alternative. The maximum does not mean everyone receives jail or the maximum fine.

Where legally available and ordered, probation for this class A misdemeanor is ordinarily two or three years under 65.00. A misdemeanor conditional discharge is ordinarily one year under 65.05, subject to the statute’s extension provision for unsatisfied restitution. Eligibility, court findings, other convictions and the actual conditions matter; these are possible sentence structures, not promised outcomes.

A proposed disposition also requires review of lawful conditions and collateral effects. Tell counsel about immigration status, professional licensing, employment requirements, firearm issues, school obligations and related Family Court proceedings. Release restrictions and orders of protection may affect daily life before the case ends. Do not assume that a misdemeanor is inconsequential or that a particular plea is safe for every person.

What happens after an arrest or appearance ticket?

Start with the actual court, scheduled date and papers. Counsel needs to know whether you have been arrested, received an appearance ticket, been asked to surrender or have only been contacted about an investigation. Those situations require different immediate preparation. A consultation does not postpone a court date or guarantee that counsel has been retained.

The case may involve arraignment and release conditions, discovery review, investigation, appropriate motions, negotiations, hearings or trial. The route depends on the charge and evidence. Early discussion can identify expiring recordings and restrictions that need attention. If multiple cases or courts are involved, bring every notice so counsel can assess conflicting obligations.

Menacing, assault and other related allegations

Menacing should not be treated as interchangeable with a completed assault. Assault statutes address different injury and mental-state requirements. A weapon-possession allegation likewise raises questions distinct from whether an object was displayed to intimidate. Some incidents also produce harassment, stalking, contempt or property-damage allegations. Ask counsel to identify each charged offense and the evidence supporting it; several labels in a complaint do not remove the need to prove each count.

Related firm guidance: menacing overview, assault defense, domestic violence allegations, and criminal defense hub.

Discuss the allegation with Lebedin Kofman LLP

The firm represents clients in New York City and Long Island. Its Manhattan and Lynbrook offices are separate from the courts and communities it serves. Provide the county, court, current case status and next deadline so the consultation can address the actual matter. Office visits are by appointment; urgent criminal contact availability does not mean every office is physically open around the clock.

Read Russ Kofman’s profile, meet the legal team, and review the firm’s reported matters and attributed client reviews. Those records help explain the firm’s experience; they do not predict your result. No specific menacing outcome is claimed here.

Frequently asked questions

Does second-degree menacing require physical injury?

No. A person can be charged for intentionally placing or attempting to place someone in the fear addressed by the statute without causing an actual injury. The prosecution must still prove the weapon-display, repeated-conduct or stay-away-order alternative it alleges.

Is a real gun always required?

No. The weapon-display alternative includes what appears to be a firearm. The circumstances of the display and perception matter. An object’s inability to fire does not automatically defeat that theory.

Does one angry encounter prove repeated-conduct menacing?

The repeated-conduct alternative requires analysis of the alleged pattern over time and intent. A single encounter may raise a different theory. Bring dates and complete evidence so counsel can assess the actual accusation.

Can the complainant give permission to ignore an order?

Do not treat a private invitation as changing a court order. Follow the current terms and ask counsel about any lawful request for modification.

Will the case end if the complainant asks to drop it?

Do not assume so. Counsel should assess the prosecution’s evidence and procedural options. Continue complying with appearance requirements and current orders.

What should I bring to the consultation?

Bring the complete court papers and orders, the next date, witness details and an inventory of original recordings or messages. Ask counsel how to provide sensitive records securely.

646 663 4430 or request a consultation. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Legal references checked October 7, 2026.

YOUR NEXT STEP

Talk to a New York defense attorney.

Tell us the immediate issue and the best way to reach you. For an arrest, police contact, or an approaching court date, call the firm directly.

646 663 4430

Free consultation. Do not wait for a form response when a deadline is near.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney client relationship. Do not send highly sensitive documents or detailed confidential information through this form.

Call 646 663 4430Free Consultation