What is Assault in the First Degree in New York?

Assault in the First Degree in New York is a violent felony offense that involves intentionally causing severe physical injury to another person. This charge often includes the use of a weapon or actions reflecting extreme indifference to human life. It is considered one of the most serious assault charges in the New York Penal system.

What must the prosecution prove to secure a conviction for Assault in the First Degree?

The prosecution must prove that the defendant caused serious physical injury, intended to cause such injury, used a weapon or dangerous instrument, and possibly that aggravating circumstances were present. These elements are crucial to substantiate the severity of the charge. Without proving each element beyond a reasonable doubt, the prosecution cannot secure a conviction.

What is an example of a scenario that could lead to an Assault in the First Degree charge?

A hypothetical example is a dispute where an individual strikes another with a metal pipe, causing a fractured skull and a brain injury requiring emergency surgery. This scenario demonstrates intentional infliction of serious injury with a dangerous instrument. Such actions would likely result in a charge of Assault in the First Degree due to the egregious nature of the assault and its severe consequences.

What are some possible defenses against an Assault in the First Degree charge?

Defendants may claim self-defense, arguing that their actions were a necessary response to an immediate threat. Another defense could be contesting the intent to cause serious harm, which is critical to the charge. Additionally, arguing accidental harm or mistaken identity can challenge the prosecution's case.

What are the potential penalties for a conviction of Assault in the First Degree?

Penalties for this conviction include a prison sentence ranging from 5 to 25 years, probation, fines up to $5,000, and possible restitution to the victim. The conviction also results in a permanent criminal record, impacting future employment and civil rights. These severe consequences underscore the gravity of the charge.

Why is there a mandatory minimum sentence for Assault in the First Degree?

The mandatory minimum sentence of 5 years reflects the serious nature of the crime and serves as both punishment and deterrent. This non-negotiable minimum is intended to penalize severe assaults harshly and discourage such criminal behavior. The strict sentencing policy highlights the justice system's commitment to addressing violent offenses.

How does intent factor into an Assault in the First Degree charge?

Intent is a crucial element in proving Assault in the First Degree, as the perpetrator must have intended to cause serious physical injury. If the defense can show that there was no intent to inflict such harm, it undermines a core component of the charge. Successfully challenging the intent can result in a lesser charge or dismissal.

What is the role of aggravating circumstances in an Assault in the First Degree charge?

Aggravating circumstances can enhance the severity of the charge, such as if the assault occurs during the commission of another felony or targets a protected individual like a law enforcement officer. These circumstances can increase the penalties and the perceived seriousness of the offense. They add complexity to the legal proceedings and require a nuanced defense strategy.

How can Lebedin Kofman LLP help if you are charged with Assault in the First Degree?

At Lebedin Kofman LLP, we understand the complexities and high stakes involved in Assault in the First Degree cases. Our experienced attorneys meticulously analyze the prosecution's evidence, challenge the elements of the charge, and develop a robust defense strategy tailored to your unique situation. We are dedicated to protecting your rights and working towards the best possible outcome in your case.

How can you contact Lebedin Kofman LLP for legal assistance?

You can contact Lebedin Kofman LLP by calling (646) 663-4430. Our team is ready to schedule a consultation and discuss your case in detail. Reach out to us today to secure knowledgeable and compassionate legal representation.

Assault In The First Degree - NYPL § 120.10

Get Defense from Our Proven New York Attorney

Assault in the First Degree is one of the most serious assault charges in the New York Penal system. It is categorized as a violent felony offense and involves severe physical injury inflicted intentionally, often with the use of a weapon or under circumstances that reflect extreme indifference to human life. This charge is typically levied in cases where the nature of the assault is particularly egregious and the consequences for the victim are profound and long-lasting. If you have been charged with first-degree assault in New York, a skilled New York assault lawyer can help you understand your charges, protect your rights, and build a strong defense aimed at securing the best possible outcome in your case.

Contact Lebedin Kofman LLP today at (646) 663-4430 for more information.

Hypothetical Example Based on Case Law

Consider the following hypothetical scenario: A man named David becomes embroiled in a dispute with his neighbor over property boundaries. The altercation intensifies, and in a moment of rage, David strikes his neighbor with a metal pipe, aiming for his head and causing a fractured skull. The neighbor sustains a brain injury that necessitates emergency surgery. In this case, David would likely be charged with Assault in the First Degree due to his intentional infliction of a serious physical injury with a dangerous instrument.

Related Offenses

Elements and Definitions of the Offense

To be charged with Assault in the First Degree under NY Penal Law § 120.10, the following elements must be present:

Serious Physical Injury: The victim must have sustained a serious and life-threatening injury, which could result in death or cause prolonged disfigurement or impairment.
Intent: The perpetrator must have had a clear intention to cause such injury to the victim.
Weapon or Dangerous Instrument: The assault is often carried out with a deadly weapon or dangerous instrument, enhancing the severity of the charge.
Aggravating Circumstances: The assault may occur in conjunction with another felony or against a person belonging to a protected category, like law enforcement officers.

Element	Definition
Serious Physical Injury	The victim must have sustained a serious and life-threatening injury, which could result in death or cause prolonged disfigurement or impairment.
Intent	The perpetrator must have had a clear intention to cause such injury to the victim.
Weapon or Dangerous Instrument	The assault is often carried out with a deadly weapon or dangerous instrument, enhancing the severity of the charge.
Aggravating Circumstances	The assault may occur in conjunction with another felony or against a person belonging to a protected category, like law enforcement officers.

Possible Legal Defenses

Defendants facing charges of Assault in the First Degree may consider several legal defenses:

Claiming Self-Defense or Defense of Others: This defense hinges on the argument that the defendant’s actions, even if they resulted in serious injury, were a necessary response to an immediate threat of harm to oneself or others. This claim directly challenges the prosecution’s assertion of a depraved indifference to human life or intent to cause serious physical injury.
Contesting Intent: If it can be demonstrated that the defendant did not intend to cause serious physical harm, this undercuts a core component required for a first-degree assault conviction. The defense can argue that without this intent, the severity of the charge should be lessened.
Arguing Accidental Harm: By asserting that the injury was accidental, the defense calls into question whether a “deadly weapon” was used with the intent required under the statute or whether the actions demonstrated a depraved indifference to human life.
Challenging the Identification: If the defense can successfully argue mistaken identity, then the prosecution cannot meet its burden to prove that the defendant committed any assault, let alone an assault with the specific intent and under the circumstances required for a first-degree charge.

Penalties

If convicted of Assault in the First Degree in New York, an individual faces severe penalties:

Prison: Persons convicted of first-degree assault in New York can face anywhere from 5 to 25 years in a state correctional facility.
Probation: Post-release supervision for a period that may extend up to 5 years.
Fines: A $5,000 fine may be imposed upon conviction.
Restitution: Depending on the circumstances of the case, the defendant may be mandated to pay restitution to the injured party. The statutory maximum amount of restitution is $15,000, however, the court can impose a higher amount to cover the victim’s medical expenses.
Permanent Criminal Record: A felony record with long-term consequences on employment and civil rights.

Minimum Sentence for 1st Degree Assault

First-degree assault is considered one of the most severe forms of assault under the law due to the intentional and serious harm it inflicts on the victim. Being categorized as a violent felony offense, the consequences of a conviction are significant and intended to act as a strong deterrent against such serious criminal behaviors.

In the event of a conviction for first-degree assault, the law mandates a minimum sentence of 5 years in prison. This mandatory minimum sentence is non-negotiable, meaning that the judge has no discretion to order a lesser sentence based on circumstances or mitigating factors presented during the trial.

This strict sentencing reflects the serious nature of the crime and the justice system’s commitment to penalizing those who engage in violently harmful actions severely. The 5-year minimum is designed to serve both as a punishment and a preventive measure, aiming to reduce the incidence of such severe assaults by demonstrating the significant consequences of committing this felony.

It is crucial for anyone charged with first-degree assault to understand the gravity of the situation and seek a competent New York assault lawyer. The mandatory minimum sentence underscores the importance of building a robust defense to either prove innocence or achieve the best possible outcome in the face of such serious allegations. Contact Lebedin Kofman LLP today to schedule a consultation.

New York Penal Law § 120.10: Assault in the First Degree

A person is guilty of assault in the first degree when:

With intent to cause serious physical injury to another person, he causes such injury to such person or to a third person by means of a deadly weapon or a dangerous instrument; or
With intent to disfigure another person seriously and permanently, or to destroy, amputate or disable permanently a member or organ of his body, he causes such injury to such person or to a third person; or
Under circumstances evincing a depraved indifference to human life, he recklessly engages in conduct which creates a grave risk of death to another person, and thereby causes serious physical injury to another person; or
In the course of and in furtherance of the commission or attempted commission of a felony or of immediate flight therefrom, he, or another participant if there be any, causes serious physical injury to a person other than one of the participants.

Assault in the first degree is a class B felony.

Experienced and Compassionate Assistance From Lebedin Kofman LLP

In the state of New York, facing a charge of Assault in the First Degree is a serious legal matter. This top-tier felony is applied in situations where a person is accused of causing severe physical harm to another, possibly using a deadly weapon, or displaying a wanton disregard for human life. The definitions of “serious physical injury” and “deadly weapon” are tightly bound by legal terminology, and these details are pivotal in shaping the outcome of a trial.

The complexities of such a case require a defense that is both knowledgeable and strategic. This is where the skilled attorneys at Lebedin Kofman LLP step in. Lebedin Kofman LLP’s approach to defense is thorough and nuanced, aimed at ensuring the rights of the accused are upheld while meticulously scrutinizing the prosecution’s evidence. Their role is not only to challenge the components of the felony charge but also to guide clients through the legal process.

Those grappling with an Assault in the First Degree charge in New York should promptly seek competent legal representation. The attorneys at Lebedin Kofman LLP are prepared to delve into the intricacies of your case, fostering a defense that leverages a deep understanding of the law. Contact Lebedin Kofman LLP at (646) 663-4430 today and secure a team that is committed to advocating for your legal rights and freedom.

Schedule A free Consultation

Legal Team

Reviews

Case Results

Our Clients Share Their Experiences

The Opinions That Matter Most

Thank you so much for all of your advice and help!

“I can’t say enough good things about these guys. Their service is worth every penny, super responsive and have a wonderful staff. I had consulted so many other lawyers and just didn’t feel they were a right fit. From the moment I spoke to Mr Kofman, I felt so much better and confident in him. Everything he said he would do, he did. I was not charged a penny more than what I was quoted, which was surprising from my previous experiences with other lawyers. On top of that, I feel like the whole team went above and beyond for us. I highly recommend these guys to everyone.”

– Masha Liro

Leave your TRUST and CONFIDENCE to them, 100% their expertise gave results done what's the best for you.

“My case was handled by Mr.Conor McNamara. I got peace of mind and the result of my case during the pandemic, 2020 was very satisfying. My court case is in New York but I’m living in another state …”

– E.C.

I normally would not write for a criminal defense attorney but I feel like the service was so exceptional that I really wanted to.

“I dont want to go into details in a public forum, but I am very satisfied and grateful for the defense I received. I would recommend this law firm to anyone facing a tough legal situation in Manhattan.”

– Beryl Beattey

I was in a jam and this firm helped me out of it quickly and smoothly!

“When I first called on a Friday, they called back immediately which I thought was great because my issue was time sensitive and I didn’t want to wait until Monday. During the entire process, there was great communication and I’d highly recommend them for anything you may be going through!”

– Jasmine Clemente

If you need someone to prove your innocence, these are your guys!

“For the past year I’ve been fighting for my freedom. My world seemed like it was crashing before my eyes. I had 2 felony gun possession cases in Manhattan. From the beginning Russ and John were there. I was denied bail at my first hearing but they fought to over turn that so I can fight the case from the outside world instead of a jail cell. They even got my bail reduced to a reasonable number afterwards. Moving forward they faught hard and relentless. Until ultimately BOTH cases were dismissed. Miracles do happen.”

– Muhamadou Saho

Russ Kofman and his team are amazing!

“Can’t say enough good things about how the team seamlessly and professionally handled the case from beginning to end. they are dedicated, determined and extremely successful in their craft. I would recommend their services to anyone!”

– Logan Kenney

Very responsive law office that I would highly recommend for great results

“Everything in the case went exactly as promised and I would recommend them without hesitation. We had Russ’ cell and he answered questions via text even on evenings and weekends. He laid everything out play by play and we still keep in touch.”

– New Era

Lebedin Kofman LLP is INCREDIBLE!!!!!

“Arthur and his team demonstrate exceptional professionalism and legal expertise. I was so scared when I received a letter from the court but, Arthur and his team took the time to carefully explain my options and they worked with me to find a solution. Not only did they solve the problem, they got the case thrown out. I can’t praise their work enough. I’ve never written a review in my life , but, I had to for Lebedin Kofman LLP.”

– James Garland

He was able to dismiss my case and save tons of money on future fines

“Going in for my DMV chemical refusal case, I was very anxious having my license being revoked for a up to a year. The odds were stacked against me, having little hope of any positive certainty. Russ …”

– G

This law firm is extremely professional and knowledgeable.

“This law firm is extremely professional and knowledgeable. I contacted the firm via email for advice on a case, Stephannie Miranda emailed me back promptly and placed me in touch with Arthur Lebedin. …”

– Jack

He got the case completely dismissed.

“I had the pleasure of using Lebedin Kofman LLP, I was greatly satisfied, my son had a very difficult case, assault on NYC police officer, and he got the case completely dismissed. They also work with …”

– Gwendolyn

Best attorney in NYC, hands down!

“I would recommend them to ANYONE. I am so glad I hired Russ as my attorney. He was so quick and efficient with my case and kept me updated with everything. If you’re in need of a criminal defense attorney, look no further and call this firm. You will not regret it.”

– Charles Green

They worked, fought and won my case.

“I must commend Lebedin and Kofman for their excellent and professional service. They worked, fought and won my case. Their service has no parallel. Excellent, professional and humane staff. Thank you …”

– Bernadette

Outstanding. Truly professional in all ways relating to law.

“From customer service to experience in the field – I cannot recommend them enough. Answered phones on all hours, constantly available, consistently reliable. Truly appreciate all of the help, will always be recommending you all.”

– Jake Malishkevich

Lebedin Kofman has been great to me.

“They were very understanding regarding my lawsuit and did everything in their power to help me. Kelsey Was amazing, answered back in a timely manner whenever I had Questions and never made me feel uncomfortable or like It wasn’t worth it. They worked hard and ended up getting me a nice sized lawsuit. I appreciate them for all of their work and would recommend to anyone looking for a lawyer who actually cares about you and your case.”

– Johnathan Franceschi

Our Commitment

Fighting For Your Best Interest

We Have a Highly Experienced Legal Team

When You Hire Us, You Get Us

We Speak Korean, Mandarin, Portuguese, Russian & Spanish

We Offer Free Consultations In Person & Over The Phone

We Have a Proven Track Record

We Are Available 24/7

Request a Free Consultation

Please fill out the form below and we will respond to your inquiry within
24-hours guaranteed.