Tax Law Article 37, Part 2
New York Tax Law Article 37 Criminal Tax Fraud Lawyer
Criminal tax fraud cases often involve returns, sales tax, withholding, payroll records, cannabis tax allegations, exemption/resale certificates, audits, refund claims, business records, and communications with tax authorities. The defense must analyze the tax law issue and the criminal-intent issue together.
What Prosecutors Must Prove
These pages are built around the official statute and, where available, the New York Criminal Jury Instructions. The prosecution must prove the legal elements beyond a reasonable doubt, not simply create suspicion or rely on an accusation.
- A tax fraud act under Tax Law 1801.
- Willfulness, defined by intent to defraud, intent to evade payment of taxes, or intent to avoid a known legal duty or lawful requirement.
- For felony degrees, proof of a tax-loss threshold within a period of not more than one year.
- Reliable accounting, audit, return, payment, refund, collection, or remittance evidence.
- A criminal mental state, not merely an accounting mistake, civil tax dispute, negligence, or poor bookkeeping.
Key Proof Issues
| Tax fraud acts | Failure to file, materially false filings, false information, schemes to defraud, failure to remit collected tax, failure to collect required tax, tax-evasion nonpayment, false exemption/resale documents, and certain cannabis-tax conduct can qualify. |
| Degree thresholds | Fifth degree: tax fraud act; fourth: over $3,000; third: over $10,000; second: over $50,000; first: over $1,000,000. |
| Records and intent | Returns, ledgers, point-of-sale records, bank records, invoices, payroll files, correspondence, accountant communications, and audit history can matter. |
| Civil vs criminal line | A key defense issue is whether the case is truly criminal fraud or a civil tax/accounting dispute. |
Criminal Tax Fraud Degree Pages
Fifth degree · Fourth degree · Third degree · Second degree · First degree
Example of How the Charge Can Arise
A non-graphic example is a business accused of underreporting taxable sales or failing to remit collected sales tax. The defense may examine whether the numbers are accurate, whether the alleged underpayment falls within the charged degree, whether the owner had intent to evade taxes, whether accountants or bookkeepers handled filings, and whether the records support a civil-resolution path rather than a criminal conviction.
Potential Defenses
- No willful intent to defraud, evade tax, or avoid a known legal duty.
- Accounting errors, bookkeeping problems, reliance on professionals, or misunderstanding rather than criminal fraud.
- Incorrect tax-loss calculation or aggregation period.
- Weak proof tying the accused person to the filing, remittance, exemption certificate, or alleged scheme.
- Audit assumptions, extrapolations, or incomplete records that overstate tax loss.
- Suppression, subpoena, warrant, statement, or privilege issues.
Early defense work matters
Preserving documents, reviewing agency records, analyzing warrants or subpoenas, testing the government’s timeline, and preparing for interviews, arraignment, grand jury, negotiation, or trial can change the direction of a case.
Related Defense Pages
White Collar Defense · Fraud Defense · Federal Defense · Grand Larceny Defense
Talk to a New York Defense Lawyer About Tax Law Article 37, Part 2
Lebedin Kofman LLP defends serious criminal, regulatory, sex-offense, white-collar, and high-stakes felony matters throughout New York City, Long Island, and in federal matters around the United States.
Review the firm’s representative cases and media coverage, client reviews, and Russ Kofman profile.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is criminal tax fraud always a felony?
No. Fifth-degree criminal tax fraud is a class A misdemeanor. Higher degrees are felonies based largely on alleged tax-loss thresholds.
What is a tax fraud act?
Tax Law 1801 lists acts such as failure to file, false filings, false information, schemes to defraud, failure to remit collected taxes, and other tax-related conduct.
Can a tax case be defended as a civil dispute?
Sometimes. The defense may focus on intent, accounting proof, reliance, audit errors, and whether the prosecution can prove willfulness beyond a reasonable doubt.
Official Legal References
This page is general information, not legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its own facts, evidence, procedure, jurisdiction, and applicable law.
Why People Call Lebedin Kofman LLP
When a criminal allegation, DWI arrest, federal investigation, Title IX matter, or high-stakes accusation can affect your freedom, license, job, education, immigration status, or reputation, you should be able to speak with a defense lawyer quickly and get a clear plan.
- Speak with a lawyer about an arrest, investigation, court date, order of protection, license consequence, or federal exposure.
- Get early guidance before speaking with police, prosecutors, school investigators, insurers, agencies, or employers.
- Review defense options including dismissal, reduction, suppression issues, trial posture, negotiation strategy, and collateral consequences.